Home » Edinburgh Fringe » Danielle Walker: Nostalgia – Assembly George Square

Danielle Walker: Nostalgia – Assembly George Square

The performance I attended was, as far as Danielle Walker was concerned, a tough crowd, inasmuch as we weren’t exactly bent double following each and every punchline. I wasn’t wholly convinced her efforts to elicit more laughter actually resulted in more actual merriment – repeated instructions to laugh louder were almost threatening, and stood in stark contrast to the usual humility expressed by comics who are thrilled to have an audience at all during the Edinburgh Fringe, when at any given time there are so many other shows happening in so many other venues. Being told I must laugh calls to mind the frustrated parent who commands that their children must have a good time at a theme park they’ve arrived at: there’s a danger of achieving the opposite effect.

Danielle Walker
Danielle Walker

It didn’t help, either, that she spoke so fondly of her grandfather that she kept bursting into tears – was I supposed to be rolling on the floor laughing my head off whenever that happened? Elsewhere, there were other moments that Walker thought were hilarious but audiences were, she noted, not as responsive as she would have liked. This is a show, therefore, that reviews itself. There’s a part of me that wonders why this perceptive and intelligent comedian hasn’t taken previous feedback away and made adaptations to the show accordingly – her family, which the show is about, evidently has more than enough past events, characteristics and opinions between them, wonderful as they all are, to genuinely amuse an audience for an hour.

And there were parts of the story that were delightful – a campfire conversation with her grandfather (still very much alive, despite Walker’s eulogy-like tribute), which the audience sees and hears by way of recorded video footage being played back, is highly eccentric but nonetheless engaging – and over too soon. It’s sentimental to the max, and it’s evident Walker enjoys telling others about her harmless but much-misunderstood relatives. She could, however, be a little more like her beloved grandfather, and hold fast to her opinions and beliefs without giving a (insert expletive) about what anyone, including this reviewer, thinks.

3 Star Review

Review by Chris Omaweng

Danielle presents a scrapbook of memories about family and all the wonderful mishaps and experiences we share with the people closest to our hearts. Hailing from rural Townsville, Danielle reminisces of the obscure and bizarre people around her, basically her entire family.

Country Mile Productions present
Danielle Walker: Nostalgia
George Square Studios – Studio Four: 3rd – 28th August: 2.15pm

Listing information:
Show: Danielle Walker: Nostalgia
Dates: 3rd-28th August
Time: 2:15pm
Venue: George Square Studios, Studio Four
Address: George Square

Related News & Reviews Past & Present

  1. Susie McCabe: Born Believer – Assembly George Square
    There’s some well-trodden territory covered in this show – Scotland is not the same as England, and it’s true that I’ve never seen…
  2. Simon Evans and His Big Ideas – Assembly George Square
    When a left-wing comedian tears into Boris Johnson it’s one thing, but when a self-confessed right-wing comedian does it, and in the way…
  3. Dan Rath: Cockroach Party – Assembly George Square
    There’s something strangely compelling about the other-worldliness of Dan Rath, who makes occasional breaks from what comes across as a random stream of…
  4. The Brilliance of Broken Glass – Underbelly George Square
    This show ended up being a little too sentimental for my personal liking. Perhaps there have been so many stories at this year’s…
  5. NewsRevue 2019 at Underbelly George Square Edinburgh
    The thing about the current occupants (at the time of writing) of the White House and 10 Downing Street is that it is…


Scroll to Top