1984 – Theatre Royal Brighton | Review

Perhaps the main strength of this touring stage adaptation of George Orwell’s dystopian novel by Ryan Craig is the use of video technology. In an otherwise black stage, set, video and costume designer Justin Nardella has an enormous television screen within which there is an electronic eye scanning the audience as it enters and settles. For those who do not know the novel, it was written in 1948, looking forward to 1984, when the world was at perpetual war with itself and everything everyone did was seen by Big Brother owing to CCTV cameras being everywhere… Orwell was influenced not only by Hitler’s Germany, but also by Stalin’s Soviet Union.

Keith Allen in 1984. Photo credit: Simon Annand.
Keith Allen in 1984. Photo credit: Simon Annand.

In fact Big Brother himself (Nicholas Woodeson), an apparently much more genial person than one might expect, never actually appears ‘live’ but only on screen, as do eight others.

This means that Craig is able to focus his version on four protagonists, even if it does mean simplifying the tale somewhat, often having characters sitting at the side of the stage, watching the action.

Phlegmatic ‘everyman’ Winston Smith, harbouring thoughts of rebellion, is charismatically played by Mark Quartley. He not only has the sparse physique that this role calls for, but he also has a very expressive face and physicality, especially when he finds himself in Room 101 in Act Two. Here his portrayal is quite hypnotic.

Julia, Winston’s lover, meeting in secret in the forest, is played by Eleanor Wyld. She is a member of the Junior Anti-Sex League and has an earthy no-nonsense attitude, but, unfortunately, there is very little chemistry between her and Winston evident on stage.

David Birrell is Parsons, a naive neighbour of Winston and utterly loyal to the party: a minor character in the novel given more prominence here, especially in the second half where he has a terrific, very powerful scene. In fact, whereas pre-interval the play just smoulders, after the break, it truly catches alight, as it should.

This is mostly owing to the charisma of Keith Allen as O’Brien, a member of the inner cabinet who poses as a member of The Brotherhood in order to entrap Winston. Allen nicely underplays the role at first, but gradually we see his cynical, vicious side as he “plays” with his captive in Room 101, like a cat might torment a mouse it has just caught. The infamous ‘rat’ scene is as horrifying as it should be, and Allen knows just how to build this into something quite terrifying.

Paul Pyant’s imaginative lighting and Giles Thomas’ often spine-chilling sound design aid the creation of mood.

This new adaptation is a faithful retelling of the story that will be appreciated most by those looking for a play that is faithful to its source. As it should, the play slowly builds to a magnificent climax. Recommended.

4 stars

Review by John Groves

On 4th April 1984, Winston Smith, comrade number 6079, starts a diary, a simple act which puts Winston’s life in jeopardy. A clandestine love affair with co-worker Julia further enrages the authorities, but can they truly trust each other? And what of the mysterious O’Brien? Will he help them overthrow the regime, confront them with their most terrifying fears, or worse…?

Versatile actor, comedian and musician Keith Allen (The Young Ones, The Pembrokeshire Murders, The Homecoming, Pinter 3) plays O’Brien, with Mark Quartley (BBC’s Inside Man, The Tempest, RSC) as Winston, Eleanor Wyld (Macbeth, The Merchant of Venice, Shakespeare’s Globe) as Julia and David Birrell (King John, RSC, Bodies, Netflix) as Parsons. Niamh Bennett plays the Voice of the Telescreen, with Lewis Hart as the camera operator.

Ryan Craig’s recent work includes Charlotte and Theodore, which received its world premiere at the Ustinov Studio in February 2023. Nominated as Most Promising Playwright at the Evening Standard Theatre Awards in 2005, he has gone on to win acclaim for The Holy Rosenbergs and Our Class at the National Theatre, The Glass Room and Filthy Business at Hampstead Theatre.

Director Lindsay Posner returns to Bath fresh from the West End transfers of Noises Off and A View From The Bridge, and the sell-out success of The Deep Blue Sea.

 The creative team includes Justin Nardella (Set, Costume and Video Designer), Paul Pyant (Lighting Designer) and Giles Thomas (Sound Designer), with Associate Video Designer Stanley Orwin-Fraser, Casting Director Ginny Schiller CDG, Associate Director George Jibson and Assistant Designer Lorelei Cairns.

1984 is at Theatre Royal Brighton
29 October to 2 November 2024, then continues on UK tour until 23 November 2024

Author

  • John Groves

    John Groves studied singing with Robert Easton and conducting with Clive Timms. He was lucky enough to act in the British premiere of a Strindberg play at the Edinburgh Festival Fringe more years ago than he cares to remember, as well as singing at the Royal Opera House - once!
    He taught drama and music at several schools, as well as examining the practical aspects of GCSE and A level drama for many years. For twenty five years he has conducted a brass band as well as living on one of the highest points of East Sussex surrounded by woodland, deer, foxes and badgers, with kites and buzzards flying overhead.

    View all posts
Scroll to Top