This new play by Harry McDonald is not for the faint-hearted! But it is the best new play I have come across for a long time. Wow! Does it pack a punch in its 85 minutes of tight writing: not a word is wasted and, perhaps surprisingly, we come to care about its “anti-hero”, Nicky (Jake Richards).

We first meet him in 1974, aged fifteen, shaving his head in a public convenience. He wants to be old beyond his years: a gay, white, neo-Nazi skinhead. He is being watched by an older man, Mosley (Matthew Baldwin), obviously no stranger to cruising gents’ toilets.
In the following four scenes, we are given snippets of Nicky’s life over the next twenty years or so: punk, gay bar, desperate porn star and…
McDonald’s writing is so powerful that we are drawn into Nicky’s world, almost without being shocked. Director Matthew Iliffe understands fully how to make the most of the play, especially the first scene, taking it at a measured pace that never seems slow or lacking in tension, as well as the final one where he allows us, the audience, to become fully involved in what we observe.
As Nicky, Richards is superb in every respect, not only having gradually to age twenty years but also making someone whom we would normally find repellent a believable person. He fleshes out the motivation behind the persona, never mind whether we like it or not. We believe him as a punk, fascist brute, yet he has a human side as well, which, surprisingly, is easy to empathise with. But McDonald makes no excuse for his behaviour or beliefs: in fact, the play is very honest.
Matthew Baldwin not only plays Mosley – suitably evil and creepy, he is also, by the early 1990s, Nicky’s partner, and very convincing in both roles.
Gabriel, a ‘fan’ of Nicky in his punk era, is very believable in the hands of Kishore Walker, coming across as very ‘gushing’ and camp, displaying his 1970s camera with great aplomb and reminding us of the days before we all had cameras on our phones and when film still had to be developed and printed. Walker also plays Chris, who is trying to film a porn movie with limited success.
In Scene three, Nicky, now a bouncer, has ‘picked up’ (or is it the other way round?) a guy in a gay bar. His name is Bird and he is effectively portrayed by Keanu Adolphus Johnson – one continually wonders why all these guys are attracted to Nicky, especially when he treats all of them like dirt!
The imaginative, very convincing, set design, is by Nitin Parmar – a wall of white, shiny, ceramic tiles punctuated by everything you would expect to find in a public loo. In fact, he contrives to make the tiny Finborough space appear much larger than it actually is. Inventive white light (“Everyone looks different in bathroom light” as Gabriel says) is by Jonathan Chan and the much-used fight and intimacy director is Jess Tucker Boyd, causing many intakes of breath from the audience during the course of the evening!
In spite of, or perhaps because of, the steady pace of the play, I found that time sped by, I was totally involved despite most of McDonald’s characters being unpleasant people – you would cross the street to avoid meeting them, especially on a dark night or in a public convenience! This is yet another of Neil McPherson and the Finborough Theatre’s ‘finds’; a must-see play for all who enjoy well-written, well-acted and well-directed drama. Very highly recommended! But, as I said earlier, not for the faint-hearted!
![]()
Review by John Groves
1973, a public lavatory. Nicky shaves his head, watched by an older man.
Publicly, Nicky is a skinhead. And a Neo-Nazi. But right now, in this place, that doesn’t matter.
He’s not the first man Nicky meets in a public toilet, and he won’t be the last…
Spanning twenty years and inspired by a true story, Foam examines the nature of identity and the consequences of right-wing extremist ideology against the backdrop of London’s skinhead and gay scenes of the 1970s and 1980s.
With right-wing extremism again on the rise, Foam confronts the flashpoint where the terrifyingly personal and the violently political collide.
FOAM
by Harry McDonald
Tuesday, 19 March – Saturday, 13 April 2024
https://finboroughtheatre.co.uk/
Related News & Reviews Past & Present
- Review of Jam at Finborough Theatre
I wonder whether Bella Soroush (Jasmine Hyde) should have toughened up a little. Did nobody tell her when she was doing teacher training… - Review of Audra McDonald at Leicester Square Theatre
It’s a pleasant evening, filled with anecdotes and ad-libs galore. I was one of those who had only come to know who… - Harry Clarke at the Ambassadors Theatre | Review
Only two characters are listed in the programme, Philip Brugglestein and Harry Clarke, although Billy Crudup plays, in total, nineteen characters, all with… - The Seth Concert Series – Audra McDonald – Review
It wasn’t that long ago when Audra McDonald treaded the boards of the West End, in Lady Day at Emerson’s Bar and Grill… - Review of The Busy World is Hushed at the Finborough Theatre
Let’s start this review off with a quote “I refuse to prove that I exist,” says God, “for proof denies faith, and without… - Review of Rachel at Finborough Theatre
‘I hear people talk about God’s justice and I wonder.’ Angelina Weld Grimké was a mixed-race poet, scholar, playwright, feminist and lesbian icon; she… - The Taylor of Inverness at Finborough Theatre
It is certainly engrossing, occasionally moving and, above all, an unusual and excellent piece of theatre.