We are used to writers playing around with historical stories, periods and literature. Think Bridgerton and how little it relates to the actual truth of Regency London. Sometimes the title will give you a rough idea of a new play’s origin story, for example, I think that David Kerby-Kendall’s play Gay Pride And No Prejudice at the Union Theatre just may have some hint of a connection with a well-known work of one Jane Austen.

It is 1812 and Mrs Bennet (Marianne March) is planning the future. She and Mr Bennet (David Kerby-Kendall) have five daughters and it is imperative to Mrs Bennet that they each make a good marriage, and she has her own definition of what makes a good husband and therefore a good match. Money, position, attractiveness are all factors – though Mrs B does believe that wealthy men are inherently attractive. Love is not really that important but that’s not a problem as a wife is there to fulfil a role and perform her duties. Her daughter Jane (Sophie Bradley) is happy to go along with this and thinks a perfect marriage is knitting her husband’s socks by the fire. The second daughter Elizabeth (Sophie Bloor) could not be more different. She makes no bones about wanting equality with any man she marries and will not simper and bat her eyelashes simply to get wed. Desperate to get the first two daughters married, Mrs Bennet is delighted to find out that the nearby estate of Netherfield is being rented out by the wealthy, and single, Mr Bingley (Noah Butt) who is throwing a grand ball to celebrate his arrival on the Hertfordshire social scene. Mrs, Bennet, Jane and Elizabeth all set out to the ball where they quickly meet not only Bingley but also his friend/companion Mr Darcy (Michael Gillette). So far, so Jane Austen. The problem that Mrs Bennet and the girls have is that Darcy has been in love with Bingley since they were boys. Over the years, this love has grown but he knows the judgemental lens of society would never let him tell Bingley of his feelings. What to do? Should he make a marriage for the sake of propriety or should Darcy bite the bullet, admit his love and accept whatever follows?
Full disclosure, I’ve never read any Jane Austen, nor have I seen any of the film or TV adaptations of P&P. I was vaguely aware of the plot – Darcy aloof and Mrs Bennet being a social climber – and had of course seen the clip of Colin Firth coming out of some water in a wet shirt, but that was the extent of my knowledge before this show. So, what did I think of the plot to Gay Pride And No Prejudice? On the whole, I quite liked it. The story flowed nicely with some really funny moments in the script that had me laughing out loud – more of that in a moment. Personally, I would have rolled it into a single act rather than having a 15-minute interval in the roughly 110-minute run just to keep everyone focussed on the period and the wham bam moment at the end of Act I. I’m also not 100% sure of the writing of Mrs Bennet. She was a bit too much for me. Yes, she is a pushy mother in the Mama Rose vein but she was so over the top that I personally think in real life Bingley would have run a mile from her.
Mr Bennet I absolutely loved. Probably because the dryly sarcastic patriarch is pretty much me. David Kerby-Kendall has given the character wonderful lines and he delivers them beautifully so a line like “Mrs Bennet and I were deliriously happy for 18 years… and then we met” moves up from being simply amusing to absolutely hilarious. What a great character but, I think an opportunity was missed with Mr Bennet, especially if his hinted at back story was the one we all thought it was.
The four leads were nicely done as well. Jane – demure, naïve and subservient to her mother’s will, until the moment when she really lets rip and we see a totally different side of her – nicely portrayed by Sophie Bradley. As was Sophie Bloor’s Elizabeth – a woman far ahead of her time in regards to wanting to change society for the better, even acknowledging when she doesn’t come up to her own standard of behaviour. A lot relies on the relationship between Bingley and Darcy and both Noah Butt and Michael Gillette have that working well, though, based on my little knowledge, I was expecting Darcy to be much more detached and stand-offish from the events around him for more of the time.
Production Designer Bob Sterrett has created a really good set with Regency style columns and moveable furniture all in white that, with the help of George Sellis’ lighting brings Longbourn, Netherfield, and Pemberley, not to mention the odd riverbank to life so that Director Luke Fredericks can move the cast around. Interestingly the cast are on stage, watching from beside the pillars all the time. A directorial choice that initially bemused me but which I quickly accepted.
Overall then I quite enjoyed Gay Pride And No Prejudice. I think there were some flaws, particularly in the way the story ended which felt a little too easy for me, but I didn’t leave the theatre feeling I hadn’t been entertained. In fact, the longer I think of the play, the more I have enjoyed reliving it in my mind.
I left hoping that David Kerby-Kendall’s next play becomes a prequel detailing the early life of one Mr Bennet, because any character who can comprehensively explain away a man’s greatest embarrassment by comparing it to an over-excited puppy is a hero who deserves their own show.
![]()
Review by Terry Eastham
Peppered with comedy, Gay Pride and No Prejudice is the story of two men and one woman’s struggle for acceptance in an era when the few retained the right to judge the many.
Darcy has loved Bingley since they were boys. At first through the innocent lens of childhood, but now the hunger to play childish games has been replaced by a more dangerous desire. For if Darcy admits his love, will Bingley and the judgemental lens of adulthood cast him out of Society?
Cast: Sophie Bloor, Sophie Bradley, Michael Gillette, Noah Butt, Marianne March, David Kerby-Kendall
Written by David Kerby-Kendall
Directed by Luke Fredericks
Production Designer Bob Sterrett
Produced by Stephen Leslie Productions
GAY PRIDE AND NO PREJUDICE
Union Theatre
8 October to 2 November 2024