I must admit, I never jumped aboard the Heathers bandwagon when it first arrived on the musical theatre scene in the mid-2010s. However, just like the 1980s film on which it’s based, it’s developed quite the cult following, and is currently stopping off at Richmond Theatre as part of a UK Tour.

The black comedy follows Veronica Sawyer (Jenna Innes), a 17-year-old high schooler who, thanks to her talent for forging handwriting, gains entry into the exclusive clique of Heathers: Heather Chandler (Esme Bowdler), Heather Duke (Sedona Sky), and Heather McNamara (Daisy Twells). Veronica’s world takes a sharp turn when she falls for new student J.D. (Keelan McAuley), and what begins as high school drama escalates into full-blown chaos when he persuades her to poison Chandler. It’s a pretty wild ride from that point on.
The production has its high points. Gary Lloyd’s choreography in ‘Candy Store’ is slick and stylish, ‘My Dead Gay Son’ is an absolute hoot, and Amy Miles really gets a chance to show off her vocals with ‘Kindergarten Boyfriend’ in the second act. Lots of the other songs though feel quite tired in their staging. With its surreal and darkly comic tone, the production could benefit from more playful and satirical choreography and characterisation. The opening number, for instance, doesn’t do enough to capture the audience’s attention or set the tone properly. The second half of Act One also suffers from some real pacing issues, which could do more to emphasise key plot points and character shifts.
The company take a bit of time to warm up, but Innes does get there by the end of the first half, and there’s a real transformation by the Act One finale. Likewise, McAuley begins as a mysterious outsider, and the character isn’t particularly compelling at first, but this takes a real turn as J.D.’s dark past comes to light, with McAuley shifting into the true villain of the show which he plays with a menacing quality. The smooth tone of his voice which charms us in ‘Freeze Your Brain’ adopts a terrifying growl in ‘Meant To Be Yours’, in which he expresses his heinous plans.
Twells gets a bit lost in the background but finally gets a chance to shine and show off her stunning vocals in ‘Lifeboat’. Conor McFarlane brings a great injection of comedy as he sings about his ‘Dead Gay Son’ and Bowdler brings a fierce edge to Heather Chandler, though a bit more range in her portrayal could elevate the character further.
David Shields’ set sees the bricked background of Westerberg High School, with other set pieces wheeled in to take us to the various other settings in the story. Ben Cracknell’s lighting design is dynamic and colourful, doing well to cover the fact that the main set stays consistent throughout the whole show.
Whilst Heathers delivers some entertaining moments, the production as a whole feels somewhat uneven. The tonal shifts between dark satire and heartfelt drama don’t always land as effectively as they could, and some pacing issues hinder the story’s momentum. Despite this, there are flashes of brilliance, particularly from Miles whose number is probably the one I’ll still be thinking about in a few weeks’ time. Having now seen the production, I still don’t think I’ll be joining the bandwagon anytime soon, although I might give the film a watch to see what it’s like in comparison.
![]()
Review by Joseph Dunitz
Greetings and salutations! Welcome to Westerberg High, where popularity is a matter of life and death, and Veronica Sawyer is just another of the nobodies dreaming of a better day.
But when she’s unexpectedly taken under the wings of the three beautiful and impossibly cruel Heathers, her dreams of popularity finally start to come true.
That is until JD, the mysterious teen rebel, turns up and teaches her that it might kill to be a nobody, but its murder being a somebody.
The 2024 class of Westerberg is led by Jenna Innes (Les Miserables) making it beautiful in blue returning as Veronica Sawyer, having wowed audiences up and down the country last year when she first took on the role. She will be joined by Keelan McAuley (Clueless; Grease) taking on the mysterious, Jason “J.D” Dean.
Starring as the titular ‘Heathers’ are Esme Bowdler (ITV’s I have a Dream finalist) as the formidable Heather Chandler, Sedona Sky (professional debut) as Heather Duke and Daisy Twells (Heathers) as Heather McNamara.
The 2024 register is completed by Amy Miles (professional debut) as Martha Dunnstock, Lucy Sinclair (Rehab the Musical, We will Rock You) as Ms. Fleming/Veronica’s Mom, Iván Fernández González (Bhangra Nation; Joseph) as Kurt Kelly, Jason Battersby (Just for One Day) as Ram Sweeney, Alexander Service (Heathers) as Kurt’s Dad/Veronica’s Dad/Principal, Conor McFarlane (Once; Heathers) as Ram’s Dad/Big-Bud/Coach, Ben Fenwick (Pippin in Concert) as Beleaguered Geek, Madeleine Hargrave (Hairspray) as Midwestern Surfer Punk, Eliza Bowden (Heathers) as New Wave Party Girl, May Tether (Very Very Bad Cinderella; Heathers) as Drama Club Drama Queen, Jasmine Cole (Crazy Coqs Cabaret) as Young Republicanette, Kelly Sweeney (Six (NCL); Hair) – as Stoner Chick, Lewis Asquith (Heathers) as Hipster Dork and Bradly Doko (Sideshow in Concert) as Preppy Stud.
Book, Music and Lyrics Kevin Murphy & Laurence O’Keefe
Based on a film by Daniel Waters
Directed by Andy Fickman
Choreography and Associate Director Gary Lloyd
Associate Choreographer Chris Parkinson
Design by David Shields
Lighting by Ben Cracknell
Sound by Dan Samson
Musical Director Will Joy
Associate Musical Director Jeremy Wootton
Bill Kenwright Ltd and Paul Taylor-Mills present
HEATHERS THE MUSICAL
Richmond Theatre, 8 to 12 October 2024, then UK tour continues to 23 November 2024