Life is full of coincidences. History is also full of coincidences – think of the sinking of the Titanic and the plot of Morgan Robertson’s 1898 novella ‘Futility’. In the theatre, a good coincidence can be a great plot twist and is at the heart of Tim McArthur’s Small Town Boys having its world premiere at the Union Theatre.

Tom (Nathan Taylor) and Drew (Stuart Simons) are two middle aged gay men who met in a bar on Fire island, where Tom is a not very angelic performer and Drew has gone on a whim after wanting to change his life. The two hit it off and take a moonlit walk along the beach with probably more than looking at the waves rushing in on their minds. But not being randy young twinks, both Tom and Drew want to get to know each other a little before taking things further. As they talk, they realise that years ago, not only were they contemporaries on the gay scene in their hometown of Middlesbrough, but unbeknown to each other, they were also both dating Jason (Dominic Charman) at the same time. What effect will this revelation have not only on their plans for tonight but also on their understanding and remembrance of their first love?
According to writer Tim McArthur (who also directs the show), Small Town Boys is based on a true story, and there certainly is an air of realism in the three characters. The story is told in a combination of current time and flashbacks and the audience get to see Josh’s separate relationships with Tom and Drew back when they were all in their later teens and living in a small town where the gay scene was a couple of bars and a discreet nightclub that sounds like hell on earth but where everyone went. And there is a lot to like in the narrative. Whilst the chance of two people like Tom and Drew meeting like this may seem a bit far-fetched, I once ran into a woman on holiday in Italy whose parents had bought my grandmother’s house off her, so that part of the plot did resonate with me. My problem was Jason. Without giving too much away, for some reason I had real trouble understanding him and his motivation for acting the way he did. I know it’s been a few years since I was a teenager, but Jason’s actions didn’t seem logical or make sense to me.
This was a shame as virtually everything else about the play worked well. The three actors were really good with Taylor and Simmons being able to be both middle aged and teenagers at pretty much the same time with style. Plus, Taylor gave us a good part of Tom’s Fire Island act before the show started which was a great way to get into the spirit of the place. Equally, Charman’s portrayal of Jason, interacting differently with his two boyfriends, was a nice piece of acting.
Jessie Huckin’s set was really nice with additional starlight added to the Union’s already generous lighting rig to produce a romantic setting on the Firs Island beach. I do question the audience seat positioning, with some seats actually on the stage and even under the stairs. I’m not sure why that choice was made but it didn’t really make sense to me.
Overall, Small Town Boys put me in something of a quandary. Whilst the writing was on the whole really good, even a day later, Jason still confuses me, and I am left wondering if it is me missing something. The acting is first rate, and the chemistry between Tom and Drew, Jason and Tom and Jason and Drew is there for all to see, and the overall production is pretty good. But I left the theatre confused, slightly frustrated and questioning the story a bit too much to feel fully satisfied.
![]()
Review by Terry Eastham
In the summer of 2023, two strangers cross paths in the USA and discover they both dated the same boy as teenagers in the North East of England. Through a series of flashbacks, the audience witness how both men’s past relationships flourished, unaware of each other’s existence. Small Town Boys is a raw and honest show about how people perceive their first loves and how we put them on a pedestal.
Tom – Nathan Taylor (he/him)
Drew – Stuart Simons (he/him)
Jason – Dominic Charman (he/him)
Writer/Director – Tim McArthur (he/him)
Set Design – Jessie Huckin (she/they)
Costume Design – Michelle Taylor (she/her)
Lighting Design – Vittoria Verta (he/him)
Stage Manager – Elise Frost (she/her)
Music Composition and Arrangements – Aaron Clingham (he/him)
SMALL TOWN BOYS
Union Theatre, 229 Union Street, London SE1 0LR
10 September to 5 October 2024