The Fabulist – Charing Cross Theatre | Review

The Fabulist is an English version of the opera The Imaginary Astrologer by the eighteenth century Neapolitan composer Giovanni Paisiello, which was first performed in St Petersburg on Valentine’s Day 1779, when it was highly praised by allegedly tone deaf Catherine the Great, who had to be reminded to applaud because she could not tell when the music ended! Paisiello wrote about one hundred operas, all of which are totally forgotten today, with the possible exception of the 1782 Barber of Seville which was eclipsed by Rossini’s much more inspired work thirty years later. Paisiello’s operas are in a similar style to those of Haydn and Mozart, but do not, unfortunately, have the inspiration evident in the works of those composers, as this staging proves.

The Fabulist at Charing Cross Theatre. Photo credit: Mark Senior.
The Fabulist at Charing Cross Theatre. Photo credit: Mark Senior.

The Charing Cross production benefits from accompaniment from a very stylish quintet of piano, flute/clarinet and strings under the direction of Varia Doletskaya-Pidgen, using imaginative orchestrations by Bobby Goulder. Direction, by John Walton, encourages the six-strong cast to a great deal of physical energy in portraying their roles. Stuart Pendred, as Cardinal Bandini, possesses a fine bass voice and acts with gusto, as does James Paterson in the role of Count Petronius, the astrologer. His daughters Cassandra (Lily de la Haye) and Clarice (Reka Jonas) are, for some unexplained reason, running a silent film company in 1927 Tuscany: this thread of the plot seems important at the start of the opera, but is then forgotten about until the very end! Both possess striking voices, but are over amplified (Andrew Johnson) using radio mikes, so that the sound they produce is strident and unpleasant. Surely, in a venue of this size, voice amplification is unnecessary? All on stage exhibit voices that are more than powerful enough to project to the rear of the theatre without artificial aid!

Dan Smith is a youthful Julian, the “Fabulist” or magician/conjuror of the title, possessing a pleasant, light voice and Constantine Andronikou plays his side-kick Puppini.

The rather confusing set is by David Shields, who is also responsible for some colourful costumes, and some quite magical illusions have been created by Harry de Cruz. These are, in fact, the most successful parts of the production.

The new English/American dialogue (replacing the original sung Italian recitative) and lyrics are by “cyber war and strategic communication” expert James Farwell. This appears to be his first attempt at writing an opera libretto. He has jettisoned much of the original plot and says in a programme note that “The Fabulist is a reflection on how one might ascertain the authenticity of love, and the interplay of science and magic as an itinerant magician“.  Unfortunately, there is far too much dialogue between musical numbers, much of it being very pedestrian and not amusing when it is trying to be. The cast and director do their best to give the piece much-needed energy but Act Two especially seems much longer than it is owing, for example, to a drawn-out scene discussing wine.

As to the title of the piece, Harwell also informs us that “top magicians often refer to themselves as ‘fabulists’…magic and science offer parallel paths to truth“.

It is a pity that Farwell did not hit upon a neglected opera with more musical merit than this one to adapt for twenty-first-century audiences.

2 gold stars

Review by John Groves

The Fabulist, with book and lyrics by James Farwell, is based on Paisiello’s opera The Imaginary Astrologer, Catherine the Great’s favourite, written specially for her. Paisiello, who heavily influenced Rossini but with a lighter tone, was the favourite composer of both Catherine and Napoleon, for whom he composed Coronation music.

CAST
Dan Smith – Julian
James Paterson – Count Petronius
Stuart Pendred – Cardinal Bandini
Constantine Andronikou – Puppupini
Réka Jónás – Clarice
Lily De La Haye – Cassandra
Jack Holton – Alternate Julian
Marienella Phillips – Alternate Cassandra and Clarice

CREATIVE
Director John Walton
Musical Director & Orchestrator Bobby Goulder
Movement Director Sean Kempton
Set and Costume Designer David Shields
Lighting Designer Fridthjofur Thorsteinsson
Sound Designer Andrew Johnson
Magic Consultant Harry De Cruz
Casting Director Debbie O’Brien
Producer Steven Levy for Charing Cross Theatre Productions

THE FABULIST
Charing Cross Theatre
12 August to 21 September 2024

Author

  • John Groves

    John Groves studied singing with Robert Easton and conducting with Clive Timms. He was lucky enough to act in the British premiere of a Strindberg play at the Edinburgh Festival Fringe more years ago than he cares to remember, as well as singing at the Royal Opera House - once!
    He taught drama and music at several schools, as well as examining the practical aspects of GCSE and A level drama for many years. For twenty five years he has conducted a brass band as well as living on one of the highest points of East Sussex surrounded by woodland, deer, foxes and badgers, with kites and buzzards flying overhead.

    View all posts
Scroll to Top